[identity profile] spikiegirl.livejournal.com

French cover

Living Dead in Dallas (Sookie Stackhouse, Book 2)
by Charlaine Harris
 
Synopsis: "Cocktail waitress Sookie Stackhouse is having a streak of bad luck. First her co-worker is killed, and no one seems to care. Then she comes face-to-face with a beastly creature which gives her a painful and poisonous lashing. Enter the vampires, who graciously suck the poison from her veins (like they didn't enjoy it). The point is: they saved her life. So when one of the bloodsuckers asks for a favour, she obliges - and soon Sookie's in Dallas, using her telepathic skills to search for a missing vampire. She's supposed to interview certain humans involved, but she makes one condition: the vampires must promise to behave, and let the humans go unharmed. But that's easier said than done, and all it takes is one delicious blonde and one small mistake for things to turn deadly." (From Amazon.co.uk)


My Opinion: I said previously that despite my disappointment with the first novel I would read the second one, which I did, and I want to say "Hallelujah!", finally some actions!! As you can guess, I liked this 2nd installment much better than the previous one. The main story was interesting even if after reading books like "The Mercedes Thompson series" or "The Anita Black series", it still lacked some excitement and a more tricky plot... but I can't complain too much on this point as it's a real improvement (it is for me at least).

Nevertheless, there were still a few things that I didn't like:
1) Sookie. I'm sorry to all her fans but I really don't like her. A few times, I had to close the book for a minute because she annoyed me too much. She seems so contradictory to me sometimes like she's not reacting as she should, I don't know how to explain ^^'
So yeah for now, she's in my list of "main characters I want to slap" along with Bella Swan lol

2) Bill & Sookie's love story. For some reasons, each time he talks sweetly to her it gives me the creeps. In French, he calls her "Mon amour" which means "My love", I don't know how it's originally written but the first time I read it, I wanted to close the book and not open it again lol. I don't know maybe because I'm not used to that from a vampire character, it sounds wrong in my ears ^^". Anyway, I don't really like Bill too, he lacks some "punch" especially compared to Eric.

3) The Maenad story was totally useless. Actually I was excited to read about this plot since it was the first time I encountered a maenad character in a novel and thought it would play a bigger part but it didn't. In fact, that story seemed once again totally botched (I'm starting to get used to with this author :s). When I finished the book, I wondered what was the purpose of it except increase the number of pages. No wait, it actually brought something great: Eric XD. I love this guy... ok this vampire... he's funny, hot and "dangerous". Ah~ if he's more present in the following novels, it may make me want to read them XD


To summarize: Much better than the 1st novel but I'll read the following ones only if Eric plays a bigger part and/or if other interesting characters like him are introduced (and do play a real role) because currently, the characters don't interest me at all.

Oh and for those who may have not read it yet, you should know that there are sex scenes so it's not for the younger readers. I didn't talk about them because they left me rather "blank"... except when there's Eric... I said I love him XDD
[identity profile] spikiegirl.livejournal.com

French cover
 
Dead Until Dark (Sookie Stackhouse, Book 1)
by Charlaine Harris

Synopsis: "Sookie Stackhouse is a small-time cocktail waitress in small-town Louisiana. She's quiet, keeps to herself, and doesn't get out much - not because she's not pretty - she's a very cute bubbly blonde - or not interested in a social life. She really is . . . but Sookie's got a bit of a disability. She can read minds. And that doesn't make her too dateable. And then along comes Bill: he's tall, he's dark and he's handsome - and Sookie can't 'hear' a word he's thinking. He's exactly the type of guy she's been waiting all her life for. But Bill has a disability of his own: he's fussy about his food, he doesn't like suntans and he's never around during the day . . . Yep, Bill's a vampire. Worse than that, he hangs with a seriously creepy crowd, with a reputation for trouble - of the murderous kind. And then one of Sookie's colleagues at the bar is killed, and it's beginning to look like Sookie might be the next victim..." (Taken from Amazon.co.uk)


My Opinion: Hmm what can I say? I must admit I'm disappointed by this novel. After hearing so much about the TV series and the novels, I thought that it would be THE book that makes me addicted... unfortunately it wasn't. I'm not saying I hated it but just that I was expecting much more.
First, you have to know I read this book in French so maybe it would have been better in English but I'm not sure ^^'. Moreover, you should know that I watched the first 4 episodes of "True Blood" some time ago (never had the time nor truly the great desire to watch the rest) so the first chapters were very familiar to me as the 1st season = the 1st novel... how they managed to last 12 episodes with this single novel is such a wonder that now I feel the need to watch the rest.
Let's talk about what I didn't appreciate first so we can end on a more positive note.

1) The characters. I didn't appreciate any of the characters. Ok, Sookie is much less a nitwit than in the TV show but she's not lovable in any way in my opinion. What annoyed me was the lack of depth in the characters, everything seems to be on the superficial side, there are no real development in any of them. I'm aware this is a series so they can't say everything in the first book but damn, you also have to make us want to read more, I didn't feel connected to any of them.

2) Incoherence, especially in Sookie's case. Because of Sookie's telepathic powers, people thinks she's mentally instable and some don't hesitate to make fun of her right in her face and she doesn't say a word, she doesn't tell them to go to hell, she doesn't do anything. But when she meets an old and powerful vampire who could kill her in 2 seconds, she has no problem talking back to him... hmm okay, it doesn't sound very logicial to me but oh well. In my opinion, there's a serious lack of coherence in Sookie's behaviour throughout the book. Once again that's only my opinon.
As for Bill, the vampire wants to fit in the small town so he drinks synthetic blood (good points to him) but then somewhere in the novel he only wants to drink human blood... sure you'll fit much more now O_o.

3) Romance. I wouldn't say this novel is "bit-lit" but rather "chick-lit" with fantasy. The novel focuses too much on the romance part for my taste. Moreover, I didn't "believe in" this love story, their "I love you" didn't ring true.
When I read the synopsis, I thought there'd be a real investigation on the murders but it wasn't the case... the author was too interested in Sookie & Bill's relationship... which brings me to my final point:

4) The end. I won't say much except that it was so botched I wanted to laugh. The who & why of the murders were absolutely not credible to me, it seemed like the author realized she'd have to give a name and a face to the murderer and explain their actions so she wrote the first thing that went through her head. Sorry, I don't buy it.


Now you probably wonder what good I can tell about this book: it was truly a pleasant and easy read. The writing is simple and it's good when you're in need of something light. It only took me a few hours to read it and despite my reproaches I still enjoyed it... not to the point of reading it again but I didn't feel like hiding it in the back of my bookcase XDD
Will I read the 2nd book? Yes, I think so because we can't judge a series by only the first book (except if the experience was too "facepalm" you know) and because it's so popular I want to understand why ^^'
Oh before I forget; I read several times that the series is supposedly funny... I didn't find so with this first book but that may just be me. The few episodes of True Blood I watched were much funnier (in a crazy way I admit XD). If you want "chick-lit"+vampires+fun then I suggest you read "Nice Girls Don't Have Fangs" by Molly Harper (read the review HERE)


To summarize:
- You like romance tinged with fantasy and light novels then go for it.
- You're more into strong characters, investigations, mysteries, danger? Have you ever heard of Mercedes Thompson? No, then go HERE

Profile

Mimi's Bookcase

December 2013

S M T W T F S
1234 567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 17th, 2025 02:55 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
OSZAR »